RANDY ELROD

Sensual | Curious | Communal | Free

Get Your Copy of The Purging Room

📱 Kindle $7.99 🎧 Audiobook $8.99 📖 Paperback $14.99 📚 Hardback $24.95

The Creative Dilemma — How To Identify Your Censors

Anxiety about reactions by others can cripple a creative.

When expressed at all, this fear is usually articulated as, “What will people think of me when they see what I’ve created?”

But it’s not people we’re most scared of. It’s specific individuals. The opinion of fuzzy thousands (or millions) of others isn’t what inhibits us most as we ponder our choice of subject matter.

Rather it’s the frown on a few faces that come clearly into focus: the guys at church, our pastor, our mate, our kids. We don’t mind the world knowing about our lives, but we’re not sure we want our parents to know.

Picture the person whose response to your art concerns you the most. Usually it’s a spouse or a parent. Sometime’s it’s another relative, friend, or an old teacher. It could be an admired colleague or one you don’t like but find intimidating. Whoever’s opinion worries us the most is our “censor in chief.”

That person can feel like a scowling Torquemada scrutinizing every word we write.

Neutralizing our fear of his reaction may not be possible. But imagining how we’ll deal with him helps. Simply identifying our censor in chief can be a revelation. We don’t always realize how much he directs our creativity.

And if we can temper our fear of a censor in chief’s opinion, dealing with the reaction of anyone else is a piece of cake by comparison.

Question: Can you identify your censor in chief?

If this was helpful, please share on your favorite social network by clicking one of the buttons below.

*These thoughts are the closely paraphrased words of Ralph Keyes from his extraordinary book The Courage To Write.

11 responses to “The Creative Dilemma — How To Identify Your Censors”

  1. Agatha Nolen Avatar

    Randy,
    A great reminder of how the voices in our heads hold us back.

    I started my blog and asked a friend, “What if people don’t like what I write?”

    His reply: “Don’t write for others; write because God has asked you to and it pleases Him. It also brings you joy and you feel closer to God.”

    Nuff said for me.

    1. Randy Avatar

      Nuff said for me too. Thanks, Agatha. Keep writing!! Keep creating!

  2. JR Taylor Avatar

    I have two frameworks for this.
    The first is, as an artist, the sense that God wants me to be honest in my art. And if my concern remains “what will God think of me?”, then I rest in the good news that nothing I do can make Him love me less because He forever sees in me the perfect work of Jesus. From there I not only desire, but indeed feel obligated, to be honest in my creative work, echoing I think your “A Creative’s Prayer.”

    The second is tied to this, but concerns more my role (calling?) as a leader. I often think, thanks to reading Virgil in HS, of Aeneas’ leadership example. He demonstrated a “selective honesty” for the sake of his followers for whom he was responsible. His own “reality distortion field” was necessary to lead his companions to survival.

    These two frameworks create a dilemma. I wish I had a comfortable answer for how to navigate these waters. Of course I also cannot help but think of Basil Hallward saying, “An artist should crate beautiful things, but should put nothing of his own life into them. We live in an age when men treat art as if it were meant to be a form of autobiography. We have lost the abstract sense of beauty. Some day I will show the world what it is; and for that reason the world shall never see my portrait of Dorian Gray.” …and so my head continues to spin.

    1. Randy Avatar

      Ah, yes. J. R., great thoughts. I love your usage of “reality distortion field.” That idea in and of itself is worth a long discussion.

      And, I don’t think I agree with Basil…at least on this point…Faulkner said, “A book is the writer’s secret life, the dark twin of a man.”

      I would tend to agree with Keyes, “Creatives have no alternative, any art that calls on the viewer/listener/reader’s feelings must first call on the creator’s.

      Robert Frost said, “No tears in the writer, no tears in the reader.”

      1. JR Taylor Avatar

        I’m not sure Wilde agreed with Basil either. :)
        Great quotes, especially Keyes – I love that!

  3. Keith Jennings Avatar

    Randy,

    I’ve been battling myself lately. It’s like practicing a song on the piano. No matter how many times I practice it, I know it can always get better.

    At the same time, I know the importance of “market testing” ideas and creative work. We can’t know it’s value and impact until we get it “out there” and see how people react.

    So I live in a perpetual state of releasing creative work and ideas that I know could be improved. And my anxiety emanates from knowing I will revisit that piece in the future and see it’s shortcomings. Which means I will face my own shortcomings, as an artist.

    What got me past the anxiety of other’s critiques will hopefull help me get past my own critiques. What got me past it was serving the idea, not its recipients. It’s like trying to serve God rather than His people.

    But, as with all important and complex things, it’s easier to say it than do it.

    Great post!

    1. Randy Avatar

      Keith, powerful statement: “What got me past it was serving the idea, not its recipients.” Keyes also states “Between the poles of write and be damned! and don’t write at all (you might hurt someone), all writers must find their point of moral, emotional and literary integrity.

  4. Al Haupt Avatar
    Al Haupt

    Randy, old friend, you need help. How did you get so far off center?

    1. Randy Avatar

      Thanks, Al, for your encouragement. I actually am seeing a caring psychologist. And as to center? Right now I have been challenged by him to have an audience of one. And you are not that one.

  5. randy Avatar
    randy

    Yep. Religious people are the worst censors, unfortunately. They assume they know the miles you have walked.

  6. Vince Avatar

    My Censor and Chief: Church People…waiting for me to slip up

Leave a Reply to Randy Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *